Wow! That blows my mind how the Villains screwed themselves royally.
Like I said, stacks and pot odds and multiway. Stacks were crazy deep so your jam gave them HORRIBLE pot odds. Also, if the call the have to win showdown against TWO Villains.
Heads-up I can see T calling you but not 3-way. Heads-up, remember, not knowing that a 9 is coming on the river, there is a 8-25ish% chance that the river chops everything and your hands are useless. Then the bet sizing screams bluff, especially since the flop was checked and you are jamming the BT on a checked turn too. So I can understand his rationale (I don’t agree with it due to the 3-way and the horrible pot odds) thinking, “that huge bet is air and I’m calling his bluff-ass.” Personally I am not calling those pot odds with T-high. I probably wouldn’t even call with J. Better pot odds and heads-up I definitely consider J. But with this atrocious pot odds I might even fold K here (and cry).
As for Mr 8-high, was he on crack? Even if he KNOWS that you’re bluffing, he has to have SOMETHING to catch you with. I think this may very well be the case where someone just doesn’t understand kickers and thought that this was chopping no matter what.
I had that happen once on another site years ago. A flush came on the board. I still have the screenshot. I don’t have the streets saved but several players were all-in (I was not one of them).
The board was 7 9 2 6 K - all dia
Hero won with Qdi 5ht
Villain 1 Aht Jsp
Villain 2 J5cl
Villain 3 A7cl
Villain 4 3sp3ht
Over the next few hands a debate developed over whether the pot was awarded correctly. Villain 2 became upset that he didn’t chop. A couple of us told him that Hero had the only diamond and his diamond hit the board (wasn’t outkicked by the lowest diamond) so his flush beat everybody else’s flush.
“Flush on the board is a split pot!” Villain 2 insisted.
“No, he outkicked you,” I repeated.
“Flush on the board splits. That’s the rule.”
“Only if no one has a diamond on the board.”
Then Villain 2 says this absolute gem. Brace yourself.
“I deal.”
So I said, "Apparently not very well. ; ) "
Back to the quads.
The suggestion of the value bet is good, but then maybe value bet says, “I got it,” and they fold and you don’t get paid.
I think it’s just one of those situations where no matter what you do you’re at the whim of the Villain’s cards and thoughts as to whether you get paid or not and whether you slow play, value or jam the result will probably be the same.